Showing posts with label Schools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Schools. Show all posts

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Making the Grade, Part Deux

In the interest of fairness and full disclosure, here are Wesley's grades for the school year to date in the same manner that I posted Heather's grades a few days ago:

Subject P1 P2 P3
English C A A
Mathematics B+ A B+
Health/Phys Ed A+ A+ A
Social Studies A B+
Science A
Computer Tech A
Wood Shop A+
Art A

I consider Wesley's first marking period "C" in English as an indictment more of his teacher than of Wesley or his performance. Wesley's middle school has an on-line reporting system where teachers are required to post grades every two weeks, and parents can then log on to monitor the child's progress. That system also allows teachers to post all class assignments, but teachers are not required to do so. Regrettably, Wesley's English teacher steadfastly refused to utilize that feature.

I should point out that his English teacher was not his only teacher who declined to post class assignments to the on-line site. His other teachers, though, had relatively straightforward daily assignments with an occasional project thrown in periodically.

English class was a different story. Wes had to juggle three weekly assignments due on Fridays: a vocabulary list for which he had to look up definitions, synonyms, antonyms, and etymology; a composition complete with first draft, second draft, and final draft; and answering a series of questions from a reading assignment. In addition, during each 9-week grading period, he had to complete any four projects out of nine possible choices. All four assignment types (vocabulary, composition, questions, and projects) were extracted from different scattered sections of booklets called a Partner Discussion Guide (PDG) that accompanied each book the class was assigned to read. [Much to our chagrin, we did not discover one additional unpublicized complication until later: once the class moved on to a new book/PDG, students could no longer submit projects relating to any previous book.]

Unfortunately, little of this information was made clear to Wesley, and none of it at all was communicated to me—that is, not until a knock-down, drag-out, face-to-face meeting I had with his teacher, the vice-principal, and the principal himself at the end of the first marking period. That meeting became necessary after a frequent but futile exchange of e-mails in which I repeatedly requested that assignments be posted on-line so that I as his parent could monitor Wesley's compliance.

Alas, all of this was to no avail: even after our meeting, the teacher still never posted assignments on-line in any meaningful way. However, the meeting did at least provide enough insight so that I—and more importantly, Wesley—could better determine his exact weekly and quarterly (project) assignments. From that point forward, Wesley was able to do the work and do it well, as his English grades in the second and third marking periods will attest.

I find it particularly ironic that such a marked failure in communications occurred with an English teacher, of all subjects. And I am not Don Quixote: I will not joust with windmills indefinitely. The only reason I pounded my head against the wall for as long as I did is that it feels so good when I stop.

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Making the Grade

Fourth-grader Heather brought home her report card for the third marking period on Friday. Her grades for the year to date are as follows:

Subject P1 P2 P3
Reading/Literature B A A
Writing A A A
Word Study A A A
Mathematics B B A
Science B B A
Social Studies B A B
Art E E E
Music E E E
Phys Ed E E E
Work/Study Skills E E E
Reading/Literature E E E

As frustrating as it was to see her miss straight A's just because of social studies, as a former mathematician I was pleased to see her finally get her first "A" in math (and science, too). I tease Heather and Wesley both by insisting that math is the only subject that really "counts." Their standard retort is that science is the only subject that really "matters."

Not viable—at least not for CCPS!

Denmark's finance ministry, New Zealand's Ministry of Health, the state of Nebraska, the FBI, NASA, and the NSA, among others, all use variants of the open source Linux operating system. The French military, Ministry of Culture, and Tax Authority all run the free and open source Thunderbird e-mail software on over 200,000 computers. And even Chesterfield County's own Public Library System has offered the free and open source Firefox web browser as an alternative to Internet Explorer for many years now.

When I asked the Chesterfield County Public Schools (CCPS) Director of Technology if any serious consideration has ever been given to using open source software at CCPS, she replied:

Over ten years ago, Chesterfield County Public Schools standardized our network and systems on Windows. Our servers are Windows; our software is Windows compatible and all applications either externally purchased or internally created are Windows compatible. To move to an unsupported open source solution would not be a viable solution for an organization of this size.

Open source software: demonstrably practical for all of the larger organizations listed above, but not viable for the delicate sensibilities of CCPS???